Louis C.K. made an unannounced return to comedy in New York on August 26, nine months after allegations of his sexual misconduct came to light. At the time the comedian admitted the allegations were true, but many critics felt he didn't sufficiently apologize. His surprise performance at the Comedy Cellar instantly generated acrimony, with many opinion writers, feminists, and female comedians contending that Louis C.K. has failed to properly atone for the harm he caused female comedians with his harassment. However, Louis C.K.'s defenders believe he is remorseful and has paid a substantial professional price, arguing that he shouldn't be banished from standup indefinitely. Others called for a more nuanced approach, arguing that a path for redemption in the wake of #MeToo must be possible, and that without any universal standard of how that can come about, Louis C.K. has a right to try.